By Gabi Mayoral
The term “genocide” has become the subject of significant controversy since the Hamas attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023 and the subsequent war in Gaza. The accusation is currently at the heart of a case before the International Court of Justice (ICJ), which was instituted by South Africa in December 2023. The issue has now also turned into a point of contention on college campuses, within protest movements, and in international diplomacy.
Chad Goldberg, a sociology professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison whose research centers on antisemitism, has taken a distinct approach to the ongoing controversy. Rather than concentrating on the specifics of Israel’s military actions, Goldberg has turned his attention to the historical roots of the accusation and whether it reflects longstanding antisemitic themes.
Goldberg presented his findings in a conference paper titled “The Genocide Libel Against Israel and Its Functions.” He argues that the accusation should be viewed through the lens of historical claims that have targeted Jews in the past.
Goldberg draws on the work of sociologist Eva Illouz and researcher Izabella Tabarovsky to challenge the accusation, noting that claims of Israeli genocide have been present in public discourse for decades. He also suggests that the continued use of this language signals that it is not solely a reaction to recent events in Gaza.
Goldberg characterized the genocide accusation as “a libel, a false and defamatory assertion,” in a comment to The Madison Federalist. He referenced a report by co-authors Danny Orbach, Yagil Henkin, Jonathan Boxman, and Jonathan Braverman, which he said debunked allegations of genocide against Israel.
A central concept in Goldberg’s analysis is the “Holocaust inversion,” which is the practice of equating Jews or Israel with Nazis and portraying the victims of the Holocaust as perpetrators of similar atrocities.
Goldberg puts the accusation within the broader context of blood libel, which is a centuries-old antisemitic conspiracy theory that accused Jews of murdering Christian children for ritualistic purposes. Goldberg notes that this narrative has long been used to justify the persecution of Jewish communities.
When asked about the role of antisemitism in the current debate, Goldberg pointed to Jewish organizations, such as the American Jewish Committee and the B’nai B’rith International, that have described the genocide charge against Israel as a modern form of the blood libel.
“Given all this, my major concerns about the genocide allegations against Israel are that they instrumentalize and politicize the Genocide Convention, making it harder to identify and respond effectively to real genocides, and the allegations encourage violence against Jews around the world,” Goldberg said.
Many scholars and public figures agree with Goldberg’s position. In September 2026, the Creative Community for Peace put out an open letter opposing the assertion that Israel’s actions in Gaza amount to genocide. It attracted over 6,000 signatures, including Harvard professor Steven Pinker, historian Niall Ferguson, and Goldberg himself.
A central argument among those challenging the genocide accusation is the necessity of proving genocidal intent. Under international law, the genocide label requires clear evidence of intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. Large-scale civilian casualties and destruction alone do not constitute genocide.
Israel has explicitly denied the allegations, maintaining that its military operations target Hamas and not Palestinians. The ICJ has issued provisional measures regarding Israel’s actions in Gaza, but has not yet delivered a final judgment on whether genocide has occurred.
In May 2026, the court set Nov. 22, 2027 as the date for South Africa’s next written submission, and Israel’s rejoinder is due on May 22, 2029.
Goldberg’s research also highlights concerns about antisemitism among younger people. In a 2025 survey of Wisconsin residents, he found that individuals aged 18-34 were more likely to endorse antisemitic tropes than older Wisconsin residents, even after accounting for other demographic and ideological factors.
At UW-Madison, the issue is not abstract. Pro-Palestinian protests and ongoing debate over Israel’s military campaign have brought the conflict directly into campus politics.
When asked about academia’s responsibility in addressing antisemitism, Goldberg emphasized education.
“When it comes to fighting antisemitism, I think academia’s chief responsibility is to educate students and the public about the history and changing forms of antisemitism,” Goldberg said. He further explained that antisemitism is not limited to religious hatred but has also developed racial, economic, and political dimensions. He noted that it exists across the political spectrum.
“Modern antisemitism often takes the form of conspiracy theories about Jewish power and control; targets Jews as scapegoats for social misfortunes, threats, or dangers; and depicts Jews in contradictory ways,” he said.
The ICJ has yet to rule on whether Israel violated the Genocide Convention. Goldberg’s research brings attention to the historical associations embedded in genocide accusations and the role of academia in educating students on how antisemitism can surface in modern debates.


