10 Comments
User's avatar
Mia's avatar

It is incredibly disingenuous to compare a dictatorship masking as socialism to the United States’ socialist revolution. Hitler’s party was famously known as the National Socialist German Workers' Party, even though he was absolutely not socialist: he used it to charade leftists into turning a blind eye.

Venezuela is not the “perfect example” of socialism you think it is

sciencebuildsunderstanding's avatar

The United States already implements "socialist policies" that we all take advantage of, such as roads, waste management, and the fire department. Comparing Venezuela's economy and political climate to the USA is apples to oranges. Corporations in the USA are also receiving "socialist benefits" through tax subsidies, write-offs, and buy-outs when their own corrupt, predatory practices crash the economy and bankrupt them. The American taxpayer has to bail them out. Instead of providing health care for all and paid maternity and paternity leave like other developed nations, we allow insurance companies to do everything in their power to charge you as much as possible while denying care where they can. Universal healthcare will raise taxes, but net save individuals and the country money because we're cutting out the rapacious middleman (insurance companies). "Evil capitalists." Yes, the billionaires who sit on their butts and generate wealth from their wealth and donate to politicians and campaigns to maintain the status quo and deregulate institutions to allow Americans to be freely screwed over. All we're asking is that they be taxed at an effective rate that everyone else is. They will still be billionaires!

Ryan's avatar

"What actually happened was that those social missions were an opportunity for regime leaders to steal millions of dollars. The educational quality of the educational missions was terrible and more oriented toward indoctrination than acquiring knowledge. Houses and equipment were of poor quality, and many people were threatened that, if they decided to show any disapproval toward the regime, their houses could be taken away and the programs that provided them with groceries or other goods could be suspended."

So was the problem finding ways to distribute wealth more effectively to those who need it or corruption? Your argument doesn't really show why 'socialism' doesn't work, it just shows an example of someone claiming to implement it for their own gain.

Cade Kuznia's avatar

Inadequate. The largest economy in the world switching to socialism is a fundamentally different circumstance from a petrostate with no economy to speak of. It's not that socialism fails inherently, it's just that you need to first establish the prerequisite economy and industrial base to support it.

Juanita Duarte's avatar

There is no perfect political system. You are attributing political corruption, a problem most governmental systems face, to socialism.

thoughtful badger's avatar

Countries where capitalism has been associated with extreme inequality and abuses of power: United States, Russia, Mexico, Chile, South Africa, Brazil, Guatemala, Philippines, Indonesia, Nigeria, Haiti, Argentina, Colombia, Honduras, Peru. A lot of these countries have emigrated too.

The problem isn’t socialism, it’s abuse of power, and capitalism can’t function without extreme inequality and exploitation, whether that’s within the country, or to another country.

Joseph's avatar

Ah, so this is how I find out The Madison Federalist is a conservative student group news paper that has previously posted articles that lack journalistic integrity. Interesting

Mia's avatar

A damn shame too